Best Eyeliners September 2026
Finding the right eyeliner makes creating clean, lasting eye looks simple and reliable. This independently ranked guide lets you compare formulas, shades, and applicator styles to find the best match for your daily routine.
Last updated: 1 September 2026
Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner dropped 1 position
Eyeliners: Top 5
1
Clinique Quickliner For Eyes
from £7.998 stores
from £7.99
8 stores
2
Lancome Ultra Precise Waterproof Liner
from £8.957 stores
from £8.95
7 stores
3
Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner
from £9.997 stores
1
from £9.99
7 stores
4
Shiseido Microliner Ink Eyeliner
from £9.997 stores
from £9.99
7 stores
5
Estee Lauder Double Wear 24H Waterproof Gel Eye Pencil
from £16.588 stores
from £16.58
8 stores
The Clinique Quickliner For Eyes is a retractable pencil designed for smooth, everyday lining. It features a waterproof formula and comes in 11 different colours ranging from classic black to bronze. Its pen format makes it simple to apply along the lash line without needing a separate sharpener.
Pros
Waterproof pen formula
Wide range of 11 distinct shades
Retractable pencil design
Cons
Contains 0.3 g of product
Not suited for ultra-sharp liquid wings
Lancome Ultra Precise Waterproof Liner delivers sharp, defined lines with a fluid liquid formula. With 1.3 ml of product, it provides more volume than many competing liquid pens. It resists water and smudging, making it a dependable choice for crisp wings and graphic eye styles.
Pros
Large 1.3 ml product volume
Waterproof liquid formula
Designed for precise line application
Cons
Fewer colour options than pencil alternatives
Requires a steady hand to apply
Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner is built for precision and long-lasting wear. Its liquid applicator allows you to draw thin accents or bold cat-eye wings with full control. The formula is waterproof and comes in eight distinct shades, including pink and purple.
Pros
Waterproof liquid formula
Available in 8 vibrant colours
Fine tip for versatile line thickness
Cons
Contains 0.5 ml of product
Liquid formula dries quickly during application
Shiseido Microliner Ink Eyeliner delivers intense pigment through a super-fine, micro-precision pen tip. The waterproof formula glides along the lash line and waterline to create detailed, smudge-resistant lines. It is offered in a versatile array of 10 shades, from standard neutrals to vibrant yellow and red.
Pros
Ultra-slim pen for micro precision
Waterproof formula
Broad selection of 10 shades including yellow
Cons
Very small quantity at 0.08 g
Delicate tip requires gentle application
Estee Lauder Double Wear 24H Waterproof Gel Eye Pencil combines the glide of a gel with the control of a pencil. It offers a generous 1.2 g of waterproof product that stays put through moisture and long days. The lineup features nine shades, including metallic finishes like gold and bronze.
Pros
Long-wearing 24-hour gel pencil
Generous 1.2 g product quantity
Waterproof and available in 9 shades
Cons
Gel texture can wear down quickly
Less precise for ultra-sharp wing tips
Compare specifications
| Type | Pen | Liquid eyeliner | Liquid eyeliner | Pen | Gel |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Colour | Black, White, Silver, Grey, Brown, Blue, Red, Green, Beige, Purple, Bronze | Black, Grey, Brown, Blue, Green | Black, Silver, Grey, Brown, Blue, Green, Pink, Purple | Black, White, Grey, Brown, Blue, Red, Yellow, Green, Pink, Purple | Black, Grey, Brown, Blue, Red, Gold, Green, Purple, Bronze |
| Quantity | 0.3 ml/g | 1.3 ml/g | 0.5 ml/g | 0.08 ml/g | 1.2 ml/g |
How we create the list
The ranking is updated monthly and is based on data we collect from our own platform. Products that rank highly are popular among our users while also maintaining high quality according to editorial expert assessments. Specifically, we weigh how many users follow the product via price alerts or lists, how it is rated by experts and users, as well as how much traffic it generates to stores and how well it is represented in retail. The texts on this page are AI-generated and created to give you a quick and clear overview. No products are paid placements – the ranking is driven solely by data.
