Best Eyeliners October 2026
Compare the top-rated eyeliners side by side to find the right formula, finish, and applicator for your routine. This independent guide highlights key features, pros, and trade-offs across leading liquid and pencil options. Use the comparisons below to pick the best match for your everyday makeup.
Last updated: 1 October 2026
The list is unchanged since the last update.
Eyeliners: Top 5
1
Clinique Quickliner For Eyes
from £8.386 stores
from £8.38
6 stores
2
Lancome Ultra Precise Waterproof Liner
from £16.757 stores
from £16.75
7 stores
3
Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner
from £9.997 stores
from £9.99
7 stores
4
Maybelline Hyper Precise Liquid Liner
from £4.795 stores
from £4.79
5 stores
5
Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner
from £4.954 stores
from £4.95
4 stores
Clinique Quickliner For Eyes is a waterproof pencil eyeliner designed for convenient daily wear. It comes in a diverse range of 11 distinct shades, from classic black to bronze and purple. The compact pen format holds 0.3 ml/g of product.
Pros
Waterproof formula
Pen format allows smooth application
Wide variety of 11 available shades
Cons
Small quantity at 0.3 ml/g
Not a liquid liner for razor-sharp wings
Lancome Ultra Precise Waterproof Liner delivers sharp liquid definition with long-lasting waterproof wear. It provides 1.3 ml/g of formula, offering the highest volume among the liquid options on this list. You can choose from five staple shades including black, brown, grey, blue, and green.
Pros
Generous 1.3 ml/g product volume
Waterproof liquid formula
Suitable for both women and men
Cons
Limited to 5 core color shades
Liquid tip requires steady application
Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner is built for clean, defined lines that stay put through moisture and humidity. It is available in eight vibrant shades, ranging from staple neutrals to pink and purple. Each pen contains 0.5 ml/g of waterproof liquid formula.
Pros
Waterproof liquid formulation
8 diverse color choices including pink
Fine liquid tip for precise lines
Cons
Relatively small 0.5 ml/g capacity
Liquid format requires precise hand control
Maybelline Hyper Precise Liquid Liner is a waterproof eyeliner created for sharp definition and reliable wear. It holds 1 ml/g of liquid product and comes in five practical shades: black, brown, grey, blue, and green. The fine tip makes drawing clean wings straightforward.
Pros
Solid 1 ml/g volume
Waterproof liquid formula
Comes in 5 versatile everyday shades
Cons
Fewer bright color choices than Stila or Revlon
Liquid formula is less forgiving than pencil
Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner is a versatile waterproof pencil that stands out with 15 different shades, including unique options like copper, gold, and red. It delivers a substantial 1.1 ml/g of product for long-lasting use. The smooth pen format is suitable for defining lash lines and waterlines alike.
Pros
Unmatched shade selection across 15 colors
Generous 1.1 ml/g pencil volume
Waterproof pen formulation
Cons
Pencil tip creates softer lines than liquid
Requires occasional shaping for ultra-fine tips
Compare specifications
| Type | Pen | Liquid eyeliner | Liquid eyeliner | Liquid eyeliner | Pen |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Color | Black, White, Silver, Grey, Brown, Blue, Red, Green, Beige, Purple, Bronze | Black, Grey, Brown, Blue, Green | Black, Silver, Grey, Brown, Blue, Green, Pink, Purple | Black, Grey, Brown, Blue, Green | Black, White, Silver, Grey, Brown, Blue, Red, Orange, Gold, Green, Beige, Pink, Purple, Bronze, Copper |
| Quantity | 0.3 ml/g | 1.3 ml/g | 0.5 ml/g | 1 ml/g | 1.1 ml/g |
How we create the list
The ranking is updated monthly and is based on data we collect from our own platform. Products that rank highly are popular among our users while also maintaining high quality according to editorial expert assessments. Specifically, we weigh how many users follow the product via price alerts or lists, how it is rated by experts and users, as well as how much traffic it generates to stores and how well it is represented in retail. The texts on this page are AI-generated and created to give you a quick and clear overview. No products are paid placements – the ranking is driven solely by data.
