Best Eyebrow Pencils September 2026
Finding the right eyebrow pencil makes shaping and defining your brows simple and precise. This independent ranking compares top options based on formula, shade range, and longevity so you can choose the right fit for your daily routine.
Last updated: 1 September 2026
Benefit Precisely My Brow Pencil climbed 1 position
Benefit Gimme Brow dropped 1 position
Eyebrow Pencils & Eyebrow Gel: Top 5
1
Benefit Precisely My Brow Pencil
from £11.006 stores
1
from £11.00
6 stores
2
Benefit Gimme Brow
from £9.999 stores
1
from £9.99
9 stores
3
Benefit 24 Hour Brow Setter Clear Gel
from £7.993 stores
from £7.99
3 stores
4
Clinique Quickliner For Brows
from £14.996 stores
from £14.99
6 stores
5
Anastasia Beverly Hills Dipbrow Pomade
from £11.985 stores
from £11.98
5 stores
Benefit Precisely My Brow Pencil features an ultra-fine tip designed for creating crisp, hair-like strokes. Its waterproof formula resists smudging throughout the day, while the integrated spoolie helps blend lines seamlessly for a natural finish.
Pros
Waterproof formula
Integrated spoolie brush
Broad shade selection
Ultra-fine tip for hair-like strokes
Cons
Small 0.08 g quantity
Can run out quickly with daily use
Benefit Gimme Brow is designed to add quick tint, definition, and fuller texture using a built-in applicator brush. The waterproof formula keeps hairs in place throughout the day while offering convenient swipe-and-go application.
Pros
Waterproof formula
Integrated brush applicator
Generous 3 ml quantity
Adds volume and tint quickly
Cons
Less precise than ultra-fine pencils
Fewer shade options available
Benefit 24 Hour Brow Setter is a clear shaping gel that locks brow hairs in place from root to tip. It comes in a generous 7 ml tube with an integrated wand that evenly coats each hair without altering your natural eyebrow color.
Pros
Generous 7 ml quantity
Integrated custom brush
Clear formula suits any brow color
Locks brow hairs in place
Cons
Provides no tint or color
Does not fill in sparse areas
Clinique Quickliner For Brows offers a waterproof twist-up formula designed for easy, controlled eyebrow shaping. Its slim design allows for detailed filling and defining across several natural color options.
Pros
Waterproof formula
Slim twist-up pencil format
Multiple natural shade options
Cons
Small 0.06 g quantity
No integrated spoolie brush
Anastasia Beverly Hills Dipbrow Pomade is a full-pigment brow formula that delivers bold definition and long-lasting waterproof wear. The 4 g pot offers a long-lasting supply and comes in an extensive selection of shades to match diverse hair tones.
Pros
Waterproof formula
Generous 4 g pot size
High pigmentation
Wide shade selection
Cons
Requires a light hand to avoid clumps
Can be difficult for beginners to blend
Compare specifications
| Type | Eyebrow pen | Eyebrow pen | Eyebrow gel | Eyebrow pen | Brow pomade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brush | Yes | Yes | Yes | — | Yes |
| Color | Black, Grey, Brown, Red, Transparent, Beige | Black, Grey, Brown, Red, Beige | Transparent | Black, Grey, Brown, Red, Beige | Black, Grey, Brown, Red, Transparent, Beige |
| Price /ml/g | 0.08 | 3 | 7 | 0.06 | 4 |
| Features | Waterproof | Waterproof | — | Waterproof | Waterproof |
How we create the list
The ranking is updated monthly and is based on data we collect from our own platform. Products that rank highly are popular among our users while also maintaining high quality according to editorial expert assessments. Specifically, we weigh how many users follow the product via price alerts or lists, how it is rated by experts and users, as well as how much traffic it generates to stores and how well it is represented in retail. The texts on this page are AI-generated and created to give you a quick and clear overview. No products are paid placements – the ranking is driven solely by data.
